Now that it's been almost two weeks since the release of Avengers: Endgame, I think spoilers are fair game. This won't be a spoiler review, but I'm going to discuss why I believe Endgame is an excellent companion piece to Infinity War. If you haven't seen either film, click away and come back to read this another time! Though my reviews for both films are safe to read if you'd like to check those out! Without further ado, let's dive into spoiler-territory.
**Spoiler Warning for Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame**
Thematically, Infinity War and Endgame are both about sacrifice. There's certainly more at play than that, but a recurring question through these two films is where do these characters draw the line? There are many contributing causes to Thanos' victory and subsequent snap at the end of Infinity War, but the Avengers lost primarily due to an unwillingness to set aside personal differences and trade one life for the sake of saving billions till it was too late.
Why The Avengers Lost
Captain America: Civil War left our main heroes divided, with Tony Stark harboring a bitter resentment towards Steve Rogers. Rogers knew that Hydra had assassinated Tony's parents and suspected Bucky may have had some involvement, but kept that information from Tony to protect his friend. However, it's important to remember that Steve offers an olive branch at the end of Civil War by sending Stark a flip-phone so Tony can call whenever he needs him. Steve is open to patching things up, but it's up to Tony to make that phone call and forgive Steve.
It's understandable why Tony was upset, but his reservation to contact Steve may have doomed the heroes from the outset. Not to mention that a majority of the Earth-bound Avengers were on-the-run or under house arrest as a result of the Sokovia Accords. Since Tony didn't call Steve and the heroes were scattered, the Avengers were unable to present a united front against Thanos. Would that alone have been enough to stop him? Probably not.
Another significant factor which held the Avengers back was Captain America's insistence that the team doesn't trade lives. A noble sentiment, but one which enabled Thanos to collect the Mind Stone eventually. Vision recognized that the stone could be destroyed and, while it would come at the cost of his own life, his sacrifice could protect half of all life. Instead, the team sought out assistance from Shuri in Wakanda to attempt safely removing the stone. Unfortunately, Shuri didn't have enough time to complete the procedure, and Wanda waited to destroy the stone at the last possible moment. Though she was successful, Thanos was able to reverse things with the Time Stone and claim his prize.
Why Thanos won
On the flip-side, Thanos wins in Infinity War because he was willing to sacrifice everything to achieve his goal and wipe out half of all life. Thanos' relentless conviction drives him to do the worst things imaginable in pursuit of balance. He conquers planets, kills half the population, submits his adopted children to physical, emotional, and psychological torture, and even pushed his daughter off a cliff to obtain the Soul Stone. Thanos justifies his behavior by believing his actions will restore order in the universe. His experience on his homeworld lead him to believe it was his destiny to spare the universe of a similar fate. In Endgame, Thanos remains devoted to his cause by destroying the stones so his work can't be undone. Even when the past version of Thanos learns of his fate, he's dedicated to the cause.
Doing Whatever It Takes To Avenge The Fallen
A recurring message in the Endgame marketing campaign has been that the Avengers were setting out to do "whatever it takes" to defeat Thanos and bring back everyone who was lost to the snap. It's only once they've lost that they truly understand what was at stake. Sure, they knew of Thanos' intentions, but they didn't think he'd actually wipe out half the universe and instantaneously disintegrate their loved ones right in front of them. Like Nick Fury says in The Avengers, "They needed the push." They're called the Avengers, but this is the first time they're actually avenging.
Atonement and reconciliation are more powerful motivators. The bitter sting of defeat has strengthened their resolve, and this time the Avengers know they must be willing to put everything on the line to possibly emerge victoriously. This time around, the team takes risks whenever, wherever, and however they can. The group collectively risk their lives by embarking on the time-travel venture and later standing against Thanos' armies to defend the gauntlet and restored order. Then, the core six team members individually jeopardize their desires for a chance at repairing the universe.
Tony sacrifices a peaceful existence with his newfound family to ensure their survival and Thanos' defeat. On top of that, he sets aside his resentment towards Steve and returns the shield because he recognizes trust and teamwork will be required to possibly pull this off. Steve leaves behind an opportunity to reunite with the love of his life so he and Tony can return to the present with the Tesseract and he can see the mission through to the end.
Thor also abandons an opportunity to dwell in the past before the destruction of his family, friends, and Asgard. Everything Thor's lost is in front of him, but he leaves because he's needed in the future. Meanwhile, Bruce Banner risks everything by wearing the Infinity Gauntlet and snapping his fingers to bring everyone back. Fortunately, the deed did nothing more than severely char his arm, but Banner was unsure whether Hulk would survive nonetheless.
Lastly, Natasha Romanoff and Clint Barton are both willing to sacrifice their lives on Vormir so the other may live to collect the Soul Stone and hopefully correct things. Considering they're assassins, they each have several sins to atone for. Barton knows that he went off the rails during his time as Ronin and is unsure he can face his family. Meanwhile, Romanoff wants Barton to have that opportunity. After all, we're told in The Avengers he made the call not to eliminate her as ordered and instead recommended she be recruited by S.H.I.E.L.D. She's finally returning the favor.
I've seen complaints that Black Widow "deserved better." Well, none of these heroes "deserve" to die. However, that doesn't render their sacrifices meaningless. If anything, Natasha's sacrifice is just as meaningful and earned as Tony's. Both are irreversible, imperative to eventually defeating Thanos, and cap off their arcs beautifully. Throughout these films, Romanoff found a sense of belonging and purpose with the Avengers. Despite all she's done, she was welcomed and accepted by the Avengers. Her entire arc is based on atoning for her past. Wiping out the red in her ledger. Now that she has the chance to contribute, why should she step aside and let her friend kill himself? Why should her choice to lay down her life mean less on account of the character's gender? It shouldn't... Black Widow's death is earned because she's given everything she can to this cause and this is the ultimate atonement. To quote Steve Rogers in Captain America: The First Avenger concerning his repeated attempts to enlist in World War II, "There are men laying down their lives. I got no right to do any less than them." Why should that statement not apply to Black Widow?
Conclusion
Revisiting my earlier observation, the lessons learned in Infinity War are imperative to the outcome in Endgame. Naturally, that should be the case for a two-part story, but these films pair nicely in spite of differing approaches. Where Infinity War focused on plot and spectacle, Endgame is more of a character-driven finale. Infinity War seems out-of-this-world while Endgame remains grounded amidst characters traveling through time and space. The through-line of sacrifice ties them together very well, and everything lost in Infinity War casts a shadow of dread over Endgame which brings the heroes down-to-Earth more so than any previous entry. Hope, unity, and sacrifice lead them to victory. The Avengers win in the end because they persisted in the face of ultimate adversity, fought together, and were willing to lay down their lives when the time was right. They were willing to do whatever it takes.
