Independence Day Resurgence is the sequel to the classically beloved blockbuster,
Independence Day, that picks up exactly twenty years later (like the time gap between the release of the films) with humanity seemingly prepared this time around, having integrated alien technology with their own.
The aliens have returned, the spectacle is larger, and the stakes are higher, yet the film never convinced me of these stakes because it failed to invest me in the characters. Honestly, this film should have been titled Independence Day: A New Generation of Mediocrity as almost all elements of the film feel lackluster when compared to the original including very uninspired editing, cheeseball writing, forgettable performances, and dull characters for the most part.
In regards to the editing, the film consistently takes the audience away from the action as soon as it gets going in order to depict
side-quests involving various characters the audience could care less about (I refuse to call it plot since it does absolutely nothing to do with remotely servicing the story). Now I'm not expecting Oscar worthy story points given the downright enjoyable cheesiness of the original, but I don't feel it's unfair to expect charm reminiscent of the first. I realize it's extremely difficult to recapture the cinematic magic that captivated audiences several years ago, especially with such a large time gap between sequels but last year two rebootquels (sequels that are effectively reboots) Jurassic World and Star Wars: The Force Awakens proved it's possible.
While I didn't LOVE
Jurassic World (I still prefer
Jurassic Park), I did enjoy it and can't deny the nostalgia of
Jurassic Park was captured incredibly well which
Star Wars: The Force Awakens did even better when attempting to restore the magic of
Star Wars.
Independence Day Resurgence strives to be bigger than the original with larger alien ships, larger aliens, and even larger spectacle and there are many moments that call back to the first but it all felt empty.
The film is oddly simultaneously great and awful, so it falls into the realm of mediocre thanks to the terrible story decisions made. On this note, I feel it's only fair I commend the wonderful visual effects to be found in the film including lots of mindless destruction, an updated CGI look for the aliens that is undeniably awesome, and the human/alien blended technology, a cool concept that's unfortunately brushed over quickly through some rushed exposition.
Returning director Roland Emmerich delivers on destruction, sense of scale, and the visuals, but elsewhere the story becomes overcrowded and convoluted due to an overabundance of ongoing events and anticlimactic sendoffs to some returning characters. Will Smith's Captain Steven Hiller was killed off offscreen piloting a new alien-human hybrid F-22. That's just how shallow the attention is towards these returning characters. I won't spoil what happens to any of the other retiring cast, but it's general knowledge Will Smith isn't returning and his demise was revealed in promotional material, so I felt I could discuss his end here.
Another big issue I have with the film is its odd pacing that simultaneously rushes gathering these characters together while taking it's time for the aliens to actually attack Earth.
ID4 cut straight to the chase by having the aliens looming over Earth with the government being unsure how to respond to the situation, building tension followed by grandiose destruction and cool sci-fi action while keeping everything tightly knit with only a few important characters as opposed to
Independence Day: Resurgence's widespread net of characters.
Speaking of which, none of the characters are really fleshed out and I think I knew just about as much information about them as I did going into the film a huge problem on the part of the film's screenplay, composed of five writers including the duo from the original Roland Emmerich and Dean Deavlin and the addition of Nicolas Wright, James A. Woods, and James Vanderbilt, and any time that a script has five writers working on it is not a good sign although I'm sure there are exceptions to that rule. The dialogue is cheesy but not in a good way, like the original, as almost every supporting actor is forcibly trying to be the comedic relief, an unsuccessful effort to say the least. There's plenty of side-stories that are completely irrelevant to the ongoings as I discussed earlier, chief among them the adventures of Judd Hirsch's Julius Levinson amidst the alien destruction that's just annoying.
As for the performances, there are few saving graces to be found. Jeff Goldblum is back reprising the role of David Levinson, and definitely brings what we've come to expect from him with some cheeseball dialogue delivery that's without a doubt entertaining. I would love to see him sign on-board to return as Malcolm for
Jurassic World 2. Goldblum's character arc feels a little hollow though as he isn't given much character growth or any drama for that matter. In fact, they completely ignore that he had a love interest in the original and never refer to Margaret Colin's Constance Spano... Instead inserting a new love interest in Charlotte Gainsbourg's Catherine Marceaux, a French alien linguist, that feels forced and is given little attention.
Elsewhere, Bill Pullman is back as a damaged Thomas J. Whitmore, a mere shadow of his former presidential self, but he does manage to recapture some of his character's charm towards the end of the film.
Brent Spiner returns as the wacky scientist Dr. Brackish Okun, who I presumed had died in the first but it turns out he was in a 20 year long coma. Spiner has the most humorous moments in the film as his comedic relief helps to bring a little life to the flick. Though, he has a love interest that comes out of left field and left me saying "Huh? Was that what I thought it was?" I don't feel his character was integral to the film, but it was one highlight.
Judd Hirsch reprises the role of Julius Levinson and as I said earlier has a side quest that was absolutely ridiculous and totally unnecessary, in fact I'm not even sure he should have returned.
Rounding out the returning cast, Vivica Fox returns for a solid 45 seconds of doing absolutely nothing. Just one of many annoyances I have with the cast, as Will Smith's absence is sorely missed.
In the newcomer camp we have Liam Hemsworth, Maika Monroe, Jessie T. Usher, Angelababy, and Travis Tope as Jake Morrison, Patricia Whitmore, Dylan Hiller, Rain Lao, and Charlie Miller, who are all pilots which makes them all blend together into a bland generic pool of characters. Few of these characters are given much depth behind them and there are attempts at romance, humor, and drama but it all falls flat as none of them exhibit much charisma or energy to energize the film but they sure do try.
One surprise to me was Deobia Oparei as African Warlord, Dikembe Umbutu, who had some really cool action scenes and made for a convincing courageous warrior, but again is a character that wasn't given very much depth. So if you can't tell from my roundup of the cast, the narrative is overstuffed with plenty of characters and so the film suffers.
In all honesty, the film is a two hour nine minute advertisement for
Independence Day 3, provided that sequel is greenlit, that I would actually be interested in seeing given the direction heavily hinted at in the film. The film has some bright spots thanks to the grandiose destruction and a few charming performances, but none of that matters thanks to mundane editing, an uninspired screenplay, and a multitude of dull characters. In summary, I sadly can't recommend seeing this followup to
ID4 as the sequel isn't any where near as great as the first.
Film Assessment: D
Roland Emmerich directs and does a great job creating a distinct difference in the scale of alien warships compared to Earth's meager aircraft and constructing authentic destruction. I liked the cinematography and visual effects utilized to hone in on the sense of scale and the nice shots of alien spaceships.
Independence Day was released twenty years ago and the effects actually help up quite well to today's standards. I like the unique look of the aliens that doesn't feel derivative, but rather inspired and the effects used to bring space ships, fighter jets, and a flurry of explosions look great. The story's simple and a little predictable feeling derivative of literally every film where Earth is invaded by aliens ever, but that doesn't take away from the entertainment value present. The screenplay penned by Emmerich and Dean Deavlin is surprisingly smart with many memorable lines of dialogue and one of the most rousing speeches ever delivered on film by Bill Pullman.
Another high mark of Independence Day is the film's cast. Led by Will Smith's fighter pilot Captain Steven Hiller the cast is full of charming surprises. Smith is probably the most charismatic of the bunch as only he can get away with knocking an alien out in one punch and then delivering the one liner "Welcome to Earth!" Smith makes for one of the film's most likable characters given his status of the everyman, a normal man with a family to protect and look after that provides Smith some opportunity to show off his emotional side.
Jeff Goldblum makes for the perfect awkward computer geek with his own struggles in life as David Levinson. Goldblum steals the show and holds his ground against Smith when the two are paired together for a final mission crucial to mankind's survival.
Bill Pullman plays President Thomas J. Whitmore and masterfully nails the feeling of authority and also the anxiety that accompany his every decision. Pullman's delivery of the aforementioned iconic speech brought chills down my spine.
Other supporting players that deserve to mentioned for being serviceable characters include Judd Hirsch's whacky Julius Levinson father of David Levinson, Randy Quaid's unstable alcoholic crop-duster Russell Casse, Margaret Colin's Constance Spano the ex-wife of David Levinson, Vivica Fox's Jasmine Dubrow the romantic partner of Steven Hiller, and Brent Spiner's mad scientist Dr. Brackish Okun.
The one thing that's executed so well in regards to characterization is how real all the characters feel. Each character seems like they could be a real person while making them interesting complex individuals or that realistically people like them would be around in this type of situation. I can't really think of any outright negatives about the film as I had fun watching it, and didn't see any slacking technical aspects.
Independence Day is a fun viewing experience courtesy of wonderful visual effects, a charming cast, and some dialogue that's hard not to forget. Sure it's cheesy at times, but it's hard to not enjoy watching Independence Day.
